Phoenix Sports Today

Phoenix Sports News Continuously Updated

Ranking Every Team’s Starting Running Back

by

NFL Running Backs

There are a lot of good running backs in the NFL right now, as the position is overloaded with talent. However, some players are better than others, and with training camp right around the corner, there is no better time to evaluate each team’s starter heading into the season.

Before we begin, a few disclaimers. This list is ranking every starting running back, so there will be exactly one player per team. It also means that players like Dalvin Cook, Ezekiel Elliott, and Leonard Fournette will not be here, as they are currently free agents. Finally, this is NOT a fantasy football article – we already posted our running back rankings in a separate article.

Ranking the NFL’s 32 Starting Running Backs

Tier 1: Elite Playmakers

1. Christian McCaffrey

After two consecutive injury-plagued seasons, Christian McCaffrey stayed healthy in 2022 and proved that he is still the best running back in the NFL. The former first-round pick is electric as both a runner and a receiver and was tailor-made for Kyle Shanahan’s friendly offensive scheme. No matter who is under center for the San Francisco 49ers, McCaffrey will dominate and has a good shot of league the league in total yards from scrimmage.

2. Nick Chubb

Nick Chubb is probably the best pure runner in football. The longtime Cleveland Brown has routinely found success despite the lack of a dangerous passing threat, and 2022 was no different. He ended the season with the third-best PFF grade in the league and could have his best season yet now that Kareem Hunt isn’t around to steal work in the passing game.

3. Josh Jacobs

Josh Jacobs is coming off of what is easily the best season of his career, leading the league in rushing yards, (1,653), total yards from scrimmage (2,053), and PFF grade (91.6). While he probably won’t be THAT good on a regular basis, there is no denying that the running back has established himself as one of the best in the business. If the Las Vegas Raiders don’t pay up for his services, somebody else will.

4. Saquon Barkley

Saquon Barkley entered the NFL as a generational prospect, and two years of injuries couldn’t take away what makes him so special. Barkley moves in ways that shouldn’t be physically possible, consistently breaking tackles, avoiding defenders, and using his elite speed to break out massive runs. This style of running is something of a double-edged sword, as he will pass up the occasional five-yard gain while trying to hit a home run. However, that’s easy to overlook when the big plays keep coming at such a consistent rate.

5. Derrick Henry

Derrick Henry is the eternal outlier among the NFL’s running backs. The running back has led the league in carries in three of the past four seasons, is entering his age-29 season, and has yet to show any signs of slowing down. While he is much closer to the end of the road than the beginning, he’s still one of the best in the business heading into 2023.

6. Jonathan Taylor

Like everyone else on the 2022 Indianapolis Colts, Jonathan Taylor is coming off a rough year. Injuries to both himself and the offensive line led to a statistical setback, but we shouldn’t forget just how good this guy can be with even the slightest bit of support. Now that he has Anthony Richardson, Taylor should be able to take advantage of easier run lanes and establish himself as one of the NFL’s best running backs.

Tier 2: Superstar Potential

7. Austin Ekeler

At his best, there is a strong case to be made that Austin Ekeler is the NFL’s best receiving back. The former undrafted free agent is one of the few running backs that actually runs routes like a wide receiver, and his ability to break tackles and avoid defenders is second to none. While he’s “just” good between the tackles, his ability to make plays on all three downs earns him a high spot in these rankings.

8. Breece Hall

Breece Hall set the world on fire during his truncated rookie season, but he’ll need to prove that he can recapture his old form before he earns a higher spot among the NFL running backs. If he plays like his pre-injured self in 2023, then he’ll probably earn a top-five spot at this point next year.

9. Rhamondre Stevenson

Rhamondre Stevenson might just be New England’s best running back since Corey Dillon. The former fourth-round pick is simply impossible to tackle on the first try and was arguably New England’s best receiver last year. Fumbles are a concern, but he excels in every other aspect of the game.

10. Bijan Robinson

Bijan Robinson has yet to play an NFL snap, but he was so impressive in college that I feel comfortable placing him among the top 10 NFL running backs. Quite frankly, he’s the closest thing there is to a perfect prospect, and if his NFL tape matches his collegiate production, he could be atop this list next year.

Tier 3: Above-Average Starter

11. Aaron Jones

Even though the Green Bay Packers offense didn’t look too great last year, Aaron Jones remained his reliable self. The running back simply refused to hand the starting job over to A.J. Dillon, finishing the season with a career-high 1,121 yards while averaging 5.3 yards per carry. With the inexperienced Jordan Love under center, Jones will need to play his best football to keep this offense moving in the right direction.

12. Kenneth Walker

Kenneth Walker is one of the most exciting young running backs in the NFL. As a rookie, the Michigan State product ripped off big run after big run while finishing second in Offensive Rookie of the Year voting. However, his lack of impact in the passing game combined with his struggles near the goal line keep him from earning a higher spot.

13. Travis Etienne

After missing the entirety of his rookie season due to injury, Travis Etienne quickly established himself as a true workhorse back, rushing for over 1,100 yards in what was effectively his rookie season. While his work in the receiving game could certainly use some work, his ability as a runner justifies this high selection.

14. Tony Pollard

Tony Pollard has looked like one of the NFL’s better running backs while splitting time with Ezekiel Elliott, but now he has to prove that he can handle a full three-down workload. If he can handle this increase in volume without sacrificing efficiency, then he’ll probably be a top-10 back moving forward.

15. Alvin Kamara

Alvin Kamara was arguably the best running back in football at his peak, but he has started to show signs of slowing down over the past few years. He’s still a good running back, but he’s not the player he was. Even if he can avoid a suspension, look for Jamaal Williams and rookie Kendre Miller to see a good percentage of the touches.

16. J.K. Dobbins

When healthy, J.K. Dobbins is one of the most efficient running backs in the NFL. Sure, sharing a backfield with Lamar Jackson helps, but there is no denying the talent on display. The only question is whether Dobbins can actually stay healthy, and if the injuries have permanently taken away some of his juice.

Tier 4: Serviceable RB1

17. Dameon Pierce

Dameon Pierce is a poor man’s Derrick Henry: a human wrecking ball that violently attacks opposing defenses but doesn’t do much of anything as a receiver. This type of player is valuable on a rookie contract, but he’s not going to stop Houston from passively looking for an upgrade.

18. Miles Sanders

The Carolina Panthers paid Miles Sanders to be a three-down back. While Sanders proved he can effectively run between the tackles, Carolina shouldn’t count on Sanders doing much of anything in the receiving game. Last year, the running back finished with a league-worst 35.4 PFF receiving grade and hasn’t recorded more than 200 receiving yards since his rookie season.

19. Najee Harris

Najee Harris touches the ball a lot, but he doesn’t do too much with his opportunities. In many ways, his on-field play is a lot like an early-career Leonard Fournette: he’ll get what’s blocked for him, but he won’t make too many plays on his own. Considering the Steelers used a first-round pick to secure his services, Pittsburgh was probably hoping for a better return on investment.

20. Joe Mixon

Joe Mixon has recorded 1,314 carries since entering the NFL, and it’s clear that all those touches are starting to catch up to the running back. The former second-round pick averaged just 3.9 yards per carry last year, and one look at the tape will tell you that this wasn’t exclusively an offensive line issue. Mixon, while still solid, lacks the muscle and explosion that made him so deadly a few years back.

21. Javonte Williams

Javonte Williams has the widest range of outcomes of any of the NFL’s running backs. The North Carolina product clearly outplayed Melvin Gordon as a rookie and showed some promise last year before suffering a season-ending knee injury. Now, nobody knows if he’ll be ready for the start of the 2023 season, or what he’ll look like when on the field.

22. David Montgomery

David Montgomery is the most boring running back in the NFL. The former Chicago Bear isn’t a bad player by any means, but he’s not a great one either. He reads his blocks well, but lacks the athleticism to break away from defenders in the second level. He’ll haul in an accurate pass, but he lacks the wiggle to make men miss in the open field.

23. Rashaad Penny

When Rashaad Penny is actually on the field, he’s one of the better runners in the league. Unfortunately, he’s not on the field very often. Assuming he’s healthy, he should beat out D’Andre Swift for the starting job, but he’ll need to prove that he can stay on the field before he earns a higher spot on the NFL’s running back rankings.

Tier 5: Replacement Level

24. Isiah Pacheco

Isiah Pacheco played well down the stretch, and he appears to be the Chiefs starting running back heading into the season. However, as detailed in his fantasy football profile, Isiah Pacheco didn’t do anything too remarkable as a runner, and his lack of impact in the passing game limits his overall ceiling.

25. James Conner

James Conner is very close to David Montgomery on the boring scale. The biggest difference here is that we’re starting to see Conner slow down, whereas Montgomery is still at his peak.

26. Alexander Mattison

Alexander Mattison is no Dalvin Cook, but the Minnesota Vikings apparently believe that the difference in talent here is negligible. Only time will tell if they’re right, but Mattison has played well in the past when filling in for an injured Cook.

27. Damien Harris

Damien Harris is a great north-south runner that provides absolutely nothing as a receiver. On top of that, he has struggled to stay on the field through the early part of his career. The good news is that Harris’ aggressive style of play matches well with Buffalo’s frigid temperatures, but the Alabama product is better off in a committee role.

28. Cam Akers

Cam Akers has had moments of brilliance throughout his tumultuous NFL career, but the running back has been far too inconsistent to earn a higher spot in these rankings. Akers finished 2022 on a hot streak, recording 410 yards and three touchdowns on just 75 attempts over the final four games. If that guy shows up in 2023, then this ranking will look foolish.

29. Brian Robinson

Brian Robinson overcame gunshot wounds to earn a starting job as a rookie. As if that wasn’t impressive enough, he also earned the eighth-best PFF grade among NFL running backs. Unfortunately, his lack of explosion as both a receiver and a runner keeps him near the bottom of this list. He might be adequate, but he’ll never be an ideal starter.

30. Raheem Mostert

Raheem Mostert runs very fast in a straight line. If you need him to do anything else, however, you could be in trouble.

31. D’Onta Foreman

D’Onta Foreman faced the unenviable task of replacing Derrick Henry and Christian McCaffrey in consecutive seasons, and he was up for the task – at least on running downs. Foreman brings absolutely nothing of note to the table as a receiver, and that’s a problem in today’s pass-happy NFL.

32. Rachaad White

Rachaad White closes out this list of NFL running backs, and he’s basically the inverse of D’Onta Foreman. While he flashed some nice hands as a rookie, he was one of the worst runners in the league by just about every metric. He’ll need to show some dramatic improvement between the tackles if he wants to keep that starting job.

Main Photo: Jeffrey Becker – USA Today Sports

The post Ranking Every Team’s Starting Running Back appeared first on Last Word on Pro Football.